There are so many different ways to trick your friends this April Fools Day. What better way to get them than when they least expect it, while they eat! Here are five super sneaky ways to fool your friends with food.

1. Oreos with Toothpaste

You can totally fool your friends by scraping the frosting out the Oreos and replacing it with a toothpaste of your choice—turning it from “Milk’s Favorite Cookie” to your mouth’s favorite cookie.

2. A Bowl with M&M’s, Skittles, and Reese’s Pieces

A trick straight from the Devil himself; Fill a bowl with M&M’s, Skittles, and Reese’s Pieces and just watch as all hell breaks loose. Your friends will slowly develop trust issues that follow themselves for the rest of their lives.

3. Deviled Eggs with Buttercream Frosting

There’s nothing worse than mixing sweet and savory in unlikely ways. Mixing a hard-boiled egg with a sweet cake frosting will leave your friends so damn confused.

4. Mashed Potato Cookies

Make a batch of cookies your friends and roommates will never forget. Instead of the normal chocolate chip cookies we all know and love, substitute the normal ingredients with mashed potatoes and black beans.

5. Candied Onions

The the worst of all options: candied onions. You may not be forgiven, but you’ll get a heck of a laugh out of their reactions.